Gov. Quinn suspends lawmaker pay until Illinois pension reform finalized
Wednesday, July 10, 2013 - ABCNews
Ben Bradley and Charles Thomas
July 10, 2013 (SPRINGFIELD,
Ill.) (WLS) -- If Governor Pat Quinn has his way, Illinois lawmakers
will not get their next paycheck if they don't act on pension reform.
Quinn suspended their salaries and his own today but the state comptroller
wants to make sure that's legal before stopping payment.
''I've tried everything in the book to get their attention,'' Illinois Gov.
Pat Quinn said after announcing he will suspend pay for lawmakers due to their
inaction on pension reform.
For more than two years now, Gov. Quinn has been setting deadlines and
demanding action on pension reform from the legislature. Time and time again:
they ignored him. His latest plan to get their attention may make headlines,
but some say it's simply not legal.
$5,653. That's how much each legislator stands to lose August 1st if
their monthly paycheck is postponed.
"Every time they've blown a deadline the taxpayers have paid. Now it's time
for legislators to understand they'll have to pay until they act," said Gov.
Quinn.
Describing it as a wakeup call for the Illinois General Assembly, Quinn
lifted the line item he vetoed. Now, lawmakers won't get their paychecks at the
end of this month.
"They must have that alarm bell ringing in their ears. And the best way
to do that is to hit them in the wallet," Quinn said.
A bill on Quinn's desk gives the Illinois comptroller the ability to issue
paychecks to state employees.
"While I understand and appreciate the Governor's focus on pension reform,
real questions have been raised about the legality of his action. Specifically,
Section 11 of our State Constitution states that 'changes in the salary of a
member shall not take effect during the term for which he has been elected,'"
Illinois Comptroller Judy Baar Topinka said in a statement. Topinka said she has
requested a legal review, which would be completed before lawmakers receive
their next paycheck on August 1, 2013.
State representatives and senators' annual base pay is just under $68,000
plus stipends for many. Their house-senate conference committee did not present
a pension reform bill at Tuesday's special session as the governor had demanded.
"I think it's a bad precedent to get into, to start punishing any government
employee with their paychecks," Senator Kirk Dillard, (R) Hinsdale, said.
"That's a childish game of tit for tat, particularly when you know the
deadline you set was impractical," Senator Kwame Raoul, (D) Chicago, said.
"At a time when we need leadership from the governor, we get another
political stunt," Senator Matt Murphy, (R) Palatine, said.
Illinois House Speaker Michael Madigan released a statement Wednesday, "The
Governor's decision follows my efforts and I understand his frustration. I am
hopeful his strategy works."
"I really feel this is the leverage the taxpayers need in order to get this
done," Quinn said.
The state's worst-in-the-nation pension debt is nearing $100 billion in
unfunded pension liability because lawmakers either skipped or shorted payments
to the state's five retirement systems for decades. Inaction on solving the
problem has led to repeated credit rating downgrades as well as a national
embarrassment. Political science Paul Green of Roosevelt University says the
payroll stop will worsen relations but not speed a solution.
"I don't think it's going to make a bit of difference. It just simply rubs
salt on a wound that shouldn't be there," Prof. Green said.
The General Assembly could return to Springfield at any time to override the
governor's veto to restore their paychecks. But Governor Quinn bets that would
be a political disaster for lawmakers to call themselves back to refund their
pay, but not deal with the debt, which is estimated to grow at $5 million a day.
"Anyone who--in the legislature--who would thumb their nose at the taxpayers
is making a big mistake," Quinn said.
Quinn also said he will not accept his salary until the General Assembly
sends him a comprehensive pension reform solution.
Legal experts say
the Illinois Constitution is pretty clear on changes to legislator pay. "The
Constitution says you cannot reduce the salary of the Legislature during their
term. Unless we have no money, we have to pay them," said Victor Filippini,
Northwestern Law School. That's the court of law, but the court of "public
opinion" is different. "It matters if legislators are prepared to go into court
and fight it. But how does that look for them to be arguing more strenuously
about their own paychecks rather than about the fiscal health of the state?"
said Laura Washington, ABC7 political analyst. Legislators we spoke with say
the Governor's arbitrary deadlines are meaningless. They say they're waiting on
actuarials to crunch the numbers on the latest proposals, and some of that
analysis isn't scheduled to be finished until the end of next week. By the
way, Gov. Quinn says he won't be taking a paycheck until pension reform is
passed either.
(Copyright ©2013 WLS-TV/DT. All Rights Reserved.)